domingo, 25 de agosto de 2013

You know the feeling when you listen to a well-produced electronic track: Everything about it seems to burst with energy, each of the elements twist and wrap organically around each another, giving the impression that the whole track is one big living and evolving ‘thing’.

But when you’re getting into producing electronic – that is, loop or grid-based music – it can be really difficult figuring out how to inject your own tracks with this sort of excitement and life-like energy.
It seems on the surface like it’s just a matter of flicking from one repeated/looped section to another: but when you try lining up the blocks of programmed drums and synths in your DAW, the result just doesn’t have the kind of energy and sense of drama that you hoped for.
Fortunately, there are loads of tricks for sustaining interest in loop-based music, disguising and blurring the various grids that you use to build your tracks on, and making them feel like living, breathing creations with a power all their own.
None of these tips are very difficult to implement on their own: but try using as many of them as possible together, and you’ll find your finished tracks positively pulse with a new sense of urgent, organic dynamism.
By the way all the tips and tricks on this list are in a sense examples of the 10 Principles Every Producer Must Know To Achieve The Pro Sound.
Compression 300x250 ad  - OUT NOW

1. Non-Sync Delay & Reverb

Try turning off tempo-sync on your delay effects, and experimenting with longer reverb pre-delay times. Programming your spatial effects manually can introduce very subtle timing ‘discrepancies’ that are surprisingly effective for loosening up the groove and giving a subtly human feel to your electronic/programmed tracks.

2. Drop In Groovy Percussion Loops To Loosen Up The Main Beat

A classic trick, but it works. Percussion loops with a nice bit of organic shuffle laid behind your main kick and snare pattern can instantly transform an otherwise heavily quantized groove. I find that trying out many different percussion loops and perhaps taking the sounds of one loop, chopping them up and matching them to the pattern and placement of another loop, can also quickly spark lots of ideas developing a lively and more original rhythm track as I write.

3. Sample Grooves And Patterns From Your Favourite Tracks

Take your favourite drum loops and grooves and use them as templates for your own patterns. You can either do this using the features of your DAW – for example the Groove Quantize functions in Cubase – or you can simply line up your own MIDI (or audio) hits manually against the waveform of the loop on a neighbouring track in your DAW, and add in your own velocity information if necessary.
This takes a bit of practice to sense where the real ‘beginning’ of some hits actually are (especially sounds with slower attacks like shakers), but once you’ve done it a few times and shuffled things backwards or forwards to taste you’ll find it pretty straightforward.

4. Program sampled instrument parts as if you were playing the real thing

Real instruments and players have physical limitations that it can be helpful to remember, in order either to give your programmed samples more realism, or simply so you don’t make your compositions too dense. To take a simple example, a drummer only has two hands (and two feet): so when he’s striking a crash cymbal at the beginning of a new phrase, he probably won’t also be striking the hihat, tom or other percussion at the same time. Incorporating little things like this can make a surprising difference to the natural ‘flow’ of programmed parts, even in electronic genres where strict realism isn’t always an issue.

5. Use Round-Robin Samples

In your sampler you can usually set a small pool of different samples to be selected from randomly every time the same, single note is triggered. These ‘round robin’ sample sets help you get around the problem of every single snare hit, for example, being exactly the same every time – even small differences (almost imperceptible when listened to in isolation) between the samples can have a profound effect on the final result, especially if you’re attempting to program dynamic fills and drum rolls.

6. Keep It Real: Don’t Just Loop Short Programmed Sections, Make Variations

While percussion parts in electronic music are almost always looped, that doesn’t mean you have to use the same short loops throughout the whole track.
Don’t simply record a one- or two-bar part and then repeat it throughout the entire track: Even if you want to have the same drum pattern all the way through, try recording it several times and mix up the different versions. Each version you create will have slightly different dynamics and timing variations, and the variety will help to reproduce the more ‘alive’ feel of a real drum track with some subtle dynamic changes.

7. Make Drum And Percussion Sounds Interact

Mute/choke groups are usually for programming realistic drum or percussion parts: for example, ‘choking’ (i.e. stopping) an open hi-hat if the closed hat is played immediately after.
However, you can also use this feature for some more unnatural but similarly dynamic interaction between your electronic drums and percussion. It’s a bit like sidechain compression, helping to gel the different elements together – the more the parts of your arrangement interact, the more alive and involving it will appear to your listeners.

8. Construct Melodies Using Counterpoint

Listen to your favourite tracks, from any genre, and you might be surprised how simple any single part is. Usually the magic happens because of the interplay between parts and instruments. The sum of all the different parts interacting creates whole new musical phrases. This is counterpoint.
Try keeping your individual synth or drum parts simple, and instead of making complex melodies with a single instrument, consider how breaking it up and voicing different elements of the musical phrase over several instruments or sounds makes it sound more fluid, engaging and… yes, alive.

9. Rhythmic Syncopation – Push And Pull The Beat And The Bass

Maybe syncopation can be considered as something like counterpoint for drums and percussion. Always think carefully about the interplay between your rhythmic elements – in dance music this is doubly important, as an interesting and dynamic groove is everything.
With 4/4 club beats the interest is usually created by highlighting various divisions of the bar around the heavy, constant and metronomic kick and snare. To get some bounce and life into your dance beats, program percussion hits to syncopate – contrast – with the main, straight-ahead rhythm.
These off-beat hits can be further enhanced by shuffling them manually forwards or backwards in small increments (see Groove Quantizing above).
This is also a major secret to the ‘driving’ rhythm underpinning all electronic dance music – try pushing or pulling either the drums or the bass ahead or behind each other and you’ll create an immediate sense of delicious tension and ‘emergency’.

10. Get solo players to play over synthesized parts for surprising realism

A trick often used by film and orchestral composers on a budget is to use sample libraries for the large orchestral parts, but to have session musicians (or themselves) play a live solo instrument over the top. This can be very effective in convincing listeners that the entire thing is a real performance.
Of course, we can apply the same methods to programming synth and electronic parts too: adding a layer of live ‘performance’ – a synth phrase or a manually automated filter, for example – to a section of fairly rigidly programmed synths and pads can liven the entire sequence up massively.

11. Tease The Listener – With-Holding Elements To Build Anticipation

Build a Compelling Structure and Arrangement: Making A Track Is Like Telling A Story
You need to begin and develop a track with just enough excitement to grab your listeners attention, but not so much that you leave yourself with nowhere to build to as the track progresses. Remember you have the rest of the track over which to space out the stunning moments, effects and hooks, so don’t pile it all up in the first section.
Gradually opening filters on synth parts over a 4-, 8- or 16-bar phrase is a great way of teasingly introducing new sections.
I sometimes think of my hooks, effects and really impressive parts of a track as currency: I want to spend them wisely, and only at the points in the track when I’ll have maximum bang for my buck – that is, maximum impact on the listener.

12. Learn The Psycho-Acoustic Effects Of Different Frequencies

There is an interesting relationship between the perceived level of excitement in a track at a given moment, and how many/which sections of the frequency spectrum are being filled.
Consider what happens on a dancefloor when the bass and drums are dropped out, leaving just a soaring lead synth: people stop dancing and instinctively put their hands in the air. They just knowit’s a breakdown. Conversely, if you strip everything back to just a driving bassline and simple drum pattern, dancers will tend to hook into the groove and concentrate on their footwork.
Mix up your arrangements by emphasizing – and just as significantly, dropping out or de-emphasizing – different parts of the frequency spectrum in different sections.

13. Master Loud/Quiet Dynamics

There doesn’t have to be any relation between the level at which an element is played back in your mix compared with how loud the original sound was recorded. This simple aspect of recording and mixing opens up all kinds of sound design possibilities that can add excitement to your tracks.
For example, you could record someone really screaming out a chorus at the top of their voice, and then mix it quite low and distant-sounding in the context of the complete mix. It will still sound like it’s being belted out, but because it’s much quieter in relation to the other elements, you’ve created a lot more depth and interest in your mix. Similarly, if you record a whisper and turn it up really loud, it will still sound like a whisper – just a very intense one, giving the impression of great intimacy between the music and the listener.
Of course this technique can be applied to any instrument or effect, not just vocals, and it’s almost guaranteed to increase a feeling of straining tension or great atmosphere within the track – listen to any Massive Attack album for some great examples.

14. Listen, Listen, Listen: Analyse & Deconstruct Your Favourite Tracks

This is one tip I come back to time and again. There’s absolutely no substitute for experience, so be sure to analyse the arrangements of all your favourite tracks. Listen to what other producers have done and try to figure out why it works (or why it doesn’t work, as the case may be…).
The more you listen, the better you’ll get at picking out the oh-so-important minor details.
You can get into massive depth here: bring an mp3 of the track into your DAW, chop or add markers at the beginnings of each new section; note which elements appear in which section, and eventually you can build a picture of how the producers arrange window would have looked.
If you’re really anal about it like me, you can actually make dummy parts, colour-coded, each on their own channel, to represent each part that you hear in your analysis track. I have found this massively helpful for really tearing apart the components of my favourite tracks and seeing what makes them tick. In fact it is like taking apart a precision clock, seeing how all the cogs and gears fit together.

15. Cross-Pollenation: Listen Beyond Your Own Genre

Look much further than your own chosen genre for inspiration. The best Pro Sound Producers are Musicologists – they don’t distinguish between good and bad styles or genres, only good and bad music.
Also, if you’re writing songs rather than club/dance tracks, study the structures used in electronic and loop-based music for some habit-breaking inspiration. And vice versa: if you’re used to making very grid-based music, listen to classical music and rock or pop for the structural idiosyncrasies that impart them with real human interest and excitement – for example, I noticed that it’s surprising how many odd bars or extra beats you can incorporate into what sounds like very grid-like system music, after noticing how in rock and metal they often make unexpected stops, starts and pauses for extra excitement and anticipation. Keep listeners on their toes, surprise them, and they’ll remain engaged.
There’s A Lot To Be Learned From Classical Music. It’s hard to specify any one thing that you’ll pick up from listening to and studying classical music, but if you use a lot of samples of real instruments in your work (and even if you don’t), listening to the work of a wide range of composers will provide plenty of ideas with regard to new textures and instrumental combinations. I remember Aphex Twin talking in an interview about getting inspiration from the ‘evil bass’ parts created by 20th Century classical composer Gyorgy Ligeti.

16. If A Part’s Not Working, Don’t Agonise – Just Bin It & Move On

This is much more difficult to do than it sounds. Keep your momentum going and don’t be afraid to slash away at your own work until only the gems remain. The knock-on affect of being ruthless and moving quickly as you work is that your parts retain a freshness that it’s quite easy to loose if you try and make things too perfect. Make sure every sound and part is pulling it’s weight in the track – remember, Less Is More.

17. Set The Perfect Tempo (or Tempos)

Many electronic music genres have pretty specific tempo ranges in which they usually work best: House between 125-128bpm, Dubstep around 140 bpm, Drum & Bass at 170 or 180 bpm.
If you’re making music that fits into a dance music genre, it makes sense to be aware of what the typical tempos are of the current tracks in that style that DJs would be mixing your tracks with.
On the other hand, other genres are far less tempo-sensitive, and it becomes more about finding the particular pace that just feels right with your groove and instrumentation. Once you’ve got a basic arrangement figured out, it can pay to just take a few minutes experimenting with the BPM: make changes of a few BPM slower and faster, and sometimes you’ll find the track just magically gels much better (even if you’ve thrown your samples out of tempo sync – you can manually fix this afterwards).
The other thing to mention about tempo is that it’s becoming more and more acceptable/exciting to change tempo during a track: either making subtle increases during a buildup (something like imitating a real drummer naturally speeding up going into a chorus) , or going all the way and making genre-hopping tempo-changes like DJ Fresh on Louder.

18. Plot Out The Structural Elements – Start The Arrangement With The End In Mind For An Organic, Uncluttered Buildup

Usually the most important sections of any song or track are the intro and the chorus (in dance or other electronic music, the breakdown/main riff reprise takes the place of a ‘chorus’). The intro sets the mood and direction of the song, while the chorus/main drop is the section that really gets under the listeners skin and becomes, in their minds, the heart and essence of the track. 
With this in mind, it makes sense to start by working on the busiest, fullest part of the track – the returning main riff. From there, you can work backwards, knowing where you’re building up to – this way you’ll feel comfortable about stripping out most of the elements for the intro and buildup sections. I find if I start at the intro, I generally add more elements than are actually necessary, afraid that it isn’t exciting enough: but this then means that in order to make the track progressively more exciting and hold the listeners attention, you have to pile on so many more elements that by the final climactic section it’s a weighed-down mess of mud and clutter. So, by starting with the final/busiest section – the signature section really – you can be confident that however sparse the other sections are, it’s alright because you’re simply building towards the goods-delivering part later.
Many problems that people have at the mixing stage, trying to get things flowing, are not really mixing issues at all: they’re space-related, arrangement issues. Listen to your favourite club tracks with this in mind, and you might be surprised to discover, when you really analyse it, how little is going on musically most of the time. This is the art of building anticipation.
Another benefit of this method is it trains you to work with a smaller number of parts for most sections, which forces you to make those parts more interesting and alive rather than just resorting to adding another instrument or part to make things more exciting.

19. Introduce a New Twist On The Existing Chords

Try laying a new set of chords underneath a part that’s already been repeated several times with its original chords. The effect is unsettling, adding tension and twisting the tune to show new aspects of itself, and once more helps to maintain listener interest.
Keep your audience on their toes – don’t feed them the same parts and accompanying chord pregressions every time. Try switching chords and riffs half way through.

20. Mix It Up: Use Sections Of Noise And Dissonance

After a certain number of repetitions, even the most catchy of choruses can begin to feel stale. When you feel you’ve reached this point in a track, try moving as far away as possible from the established harmonic/melodic content of the song, into a dissonant section. This creates a feeling of instability, which makes for an exciting  change, and also sets up for the welcome feeling that ‘stability has been restored’ when the hook/riff comes back in.

21. Powerful Melodies Always Incorporate Tension & Release On A Micro Level

Another tip for listener satisfaction: observe the rules of tension and release when working on melodies, because these two opposites provide a lot of the power of a melody. Melodies that proceed upwards usually create tension, while a feeling of release is engendered when the tune ‘descends’ from the tension point.

22. Use Creative Compression And Dynamics Processing 

Emphasise the groove dynamics with compression: Rhythmic Compression On A Drum Loop
1. Turn the ratio and threshold controls up until the signal is heavily compressed, with a large amount of gain reduction indicated on the meters.
2. The pumping or breathing effect is dependent on the attack and release controls. Set the attack to the fastest position and release to the slowest. Now move the release control through its range to its fastest position and note how the sound changes. You’ll hear rhythmic compression effects at fast release settings.
3. Now, with the release control on a fast setting, move the attack control for slower attack times and note how the sound changes. The relationship between the two controls will give many sound variations, and it should be possible to get the compression effectively turning on and off in time with the track.
4.Once you have got a sound that you like, use the Output or Make-Up gain knob to set the output level to match the next piece of equipment.

23. Execute A Blinding Breakdown

The most satisfying breakdowns strip the track back to the very barest essentials. A breakdown is all about anticipation: you are toying with the listener, so removing key elements like kick drums, basslines and hats or other percussion is a simply way of making listeners/dancers itch for the return of the complete, driving groove.
Also use silence to enable the listener to ‘take a breath’. For example, when coming out of a breakdown, try muting all the parts apart from a snare hit on the downbeat just before everything comes back. Leave the reverbs engaged though, so you get a nice bit of ambience hanging over the space.
On a technical tip, leaving a gap of silence also lets the compressors and limiters in a typical club sound-system reset themselves and lets the speaker cones retract, resulting in a drop with much more impact as the compressor kicks in fresh.

24. A Key Change

Key changes are not just a choreography cue for boybands to get off their stools for the final chorus of a ballad.
Why do key changes work? Because they can lift a song at that difficult ‘two-thirds of the way through’ stage, where the listener’s interest might be beginning to waver, and can make the same riffs and patterns suddenly feel fresh, new and that much more emotive all over again. The usual key change is to move up a tone, so if your track is in the key of A, try shifting all the melodic parts up to B for the climax section.

25. The Power Of Vocals

Never underestimate the simple power of vocals, or even vocal samples and snippets, to liven and loosen up an electronic track. Even short vocal samples can lend a surprising amount of humanization to a track.
Compression 300x250 ad  - OUT NOW

26. Use Unusual Instruments

If you’re bored of the same old sounds in your songs, try something a bit more unusual or bizarre. Of course you can even sample things that aren’t instruments at all; anything that makes a noise can be sampled, pitched (if necessary) in your sampler and used as the basis for a new custom ‘what is that cool sound?’ instrument.

27. Use Pad Sounds

Pad sounds are generally soft, sustained background sounds that don’t grab your attention but rather are used to add mood or a bit of depth to an arrangement. If your song is sounding a bit thin and lacking depth, and you can’t quite put your finger on why, adding pad sounds could be the solution.
To use pad sounds effectively, you also have to take on board the principle of sometimes making some sounds worse, EQing or processing them quite harshly in order for them to fulfill their function within the context of the whole mix. This doesn’t mean that your pads have to be always boring, however: you can use a tempo-pulsing sound or program basic filter sweeps to provide movement and interest without distracting from the main parts.

28. Change The Register Of Synth Or Pad Parts In Different Sections To Build Intensity

Related to the key change concept. The register of a part is how high up it’s played – for example, a piano part played in a high register would be played high up (i.e. to the right) on the keyboard. If every part in your track is in the same register, it’ll probably sound either dull or too dense. Try spreading parts about a bit and changing registers for particular parts as the track develops. String and synth arrangements will sound more varied and lively if you use the different registers wisely. For example, strings backing a hook section could begin in their lower registers and move up, to end in their highest: the effect is of ‘lifting’ the section and increasing its impact towards a powerful climactic moment.

29. Use Counter-Melodies For Pads & Synths

Another way to give your string and pad arrangements more realism and integrity is to create string counter-melodies which work on their own, in terms of melody, harmony and rhythm, rather than just echoing the tracks main chord progressions.

30. Be aware of listener expectations: when to indulge them, when to defy them

When arranging, It’s sometimes best to do the obvious and kick in with the big chorus at the end – it’s what people will expect and probably what they’ll want to hear. Equally, though, defying expectations and going somewhere that isn’t immediately obvious can be a really effective move.
Rules are there to be broken. It’s good to have some tried-and-tested arrangement tricks, but some great club tracks throw all the rules out of the window, so be prepared to experiment.

31. Repeat Your Hook On Different Instruments

If you’ve created a good riff or clever part, making sure to use it at least two or three times will help create a feeling of continuity. However, if you want a track that doesn’t become boring, repetition has to be balanced with novel ideas. When you listen back to your arrangement you should be asking yourself whether something new happens often enough to stimulate new interest, and also whether the best bits of the track are repeated sufficiently often for them to become lodged in the mind of the listener.
Use a hook in more than one way. It’s a classic arranging technique to have the main vocal melody played by instruments too, and this works equally well in instrumental/electronic music, for example by switching the same riff to a new synth voicing or patch for a new section: the change will usually be just as effective as if you were playing a new musical motif.

32. Let Loose: Record Performances, Embrace Accidents And The Unexpected

Anything random should be encouraged, at least initially. When you’re working with real people, you can’t be too much of a control freak if you want to get anything done, so try to adopt the same attitude with your studio tools. Try to encourage the unexpected. 75% of what happens might be unusable, but the remaining quarter may well inspire you.
Try setting up a synth track to record all of your adjustments to the sound, effects and automation data as you play it back for several minutes. Treat it like a completely free jam session. Really go crazy with it, make it a spontaneous performance, with the kinds of extreme changes or settings you wouldn’t normally consider when deep in a ‘serious’ writing or mixing session. Then bounce down the file, and scrub back through it, picking out any nice accidents or sections that spark new ideas you wouldn’t otherwise have thought of, that can be developed further.
Experiment: don’t be disheartened if 80% of what you come up with is rubbish; the remaining 20% will invariably have been worth it…

33. Learn The Typical Dance Arrangement Forms & Layered Structure

…Partly so you can then subvert it, defy expectations and make a track with an organic structure of it’s own. I.e. learn the rules, understand how and why they work, so you’ll know when you can effectively break them.
Even the most organic-sounding dance music is built in blocks., so think in 8-, 16- and 32-bar sections to begin with. But where many people fall down is in keeping these building blocks too rigid, for example keeping the exact same instruments for 16 bars and then abruptly changing everything for the next 16. To make block-based music hypnotic rather than boring, you also have to arrange by building up sounds in layers, and then either gradually stripping them away again in reverse order, or in the case of a breakdown, abruptly dropping most of them out to reveal the single layer containing the tracks lead hook.
Part of why this works so well is because it allows you to balance between the constantly repeating drums and bass for that hypnotic quality, whilst layering stuff on top brings a simultaneous sense of progression and development to the track.

34. Risers, Drops and Reverse FX for Anticipation

The first three quarters of a track generally consists of ‘build-ups’ (with intermittent breaks) anddance tracks are all about what might come next. You can increase the sense of anticipation with the use of rising or falling sound FX, reverse cymbals and automated delay or reverb effects.
Builds, Drops, Crashes & Risers
For buildups and drops the classic approach is to sample or play some white noise from a synth for the length you want, and then automate a filter sweep (usually either a low-pass or notch filter) to give you either a rushing up or ‘decompressing down’ sound effect. You can also used a tuned synth note and automate the pitch to bend up or down: pitchbends of any kind are a great way of bringing some sense of organic, sliding ‘imperfection’ to otherwise too-perfectly tuned synths and FX.
Reverse Cymbals & FX
There’s something about reverse sounds that can create ambience and anticipation like nothing else. Reverse crash cymbals are a classic choice at the climax of a buildup for ‘sliding’ into a huge drop (just listen to any Hollywood movie trailer or progressive house/trance track for proof of this).
However, there’s more to reverse sounds than the obvious buildup climaxes; if you’re making any style of electronic or club music, try incorporating subtle reversed percussion hits in amongst the main beats in your groove. For example, placing a reverse sound so that it ends just as the main snare starts creates an instant “slipped” groove effect. Somehow the reverse sounds sprinkled into a standard groove create an artificial push or pull that sounds quite similar to shuffling hits with a groove quantise – but with the added benefit that your main hits are still rock-solid on the tempo grid.

35. Remix Your Mix Stems

When mixing it’s a good idea to buss or group like instruments together for additional processing and overall control. However, a useful trick is to bounce down these ‘stems’ and bring them back into the mix project, where you can apply further processing and experiment with extra filtering, effects and edits really quickly and easily on large portions of the track. Filtering a whole mix or groups of elements in a track (such as the drums or synths) is a great way of building interest and anticipation. Removing the entire low end with a high-pass filter just before a new section generally works well, as does opening up a low-pass filter during a breakdown to build extra excitement for the drop. Of course you can do anything to your stems: chop, change, pitch, stretch and reverse whole sections if you want. Doing this with just a few stem tracks is much quicker and easier than trying to program such variations on each part individually, meaning you can make swift and organic adjustments by feel and intuition rather than with your more logical technicians hat on.

36. Finishing Touches And Details

Once your track is ‘finished’, go back through it, taking bits out here and there. Try muting synth lines, dropping drums out at the end of bars for extra impact or emphasis. You may very well find your track benefits from such 11th hour editing – sections that seemed quite stripped down at the arranging phase may have become quite busy by the time they’re properly mixed, compressed and processed with effects, so going back over each section and fairly randomly muting different parts can remind you of the ‘Less Is More’ Pro Sound principle one last time before mixdown!
You can achieve this with mute automation or simply by chopping bits out of your audio and MIDI parts in the Arrange window. This a great moment to experiment with your track, injecting that extra level of movement, energy and detail, and bringing that ‘how did they do that?’ layer of apparent complexity to your programming.

37. Use Fills

4 straight bars of a 4/4 rhythm without any variations really does suck! To maintain interest and the sense of development within a relatively sparse and hypnotic club track, drop in drum fills, subtle synth flourishes and other spot FX at least every 4th bar.

38. Programming Great Drum Beats – Use Velocity and Modulation For Dynamics

Bear in mind that the force with which real drums are struck is never absolutely consistent. To a certain extent, there will be random variation in the velocity of each hit, but there will also be more predictable variations. In pop and rock drumming, for instance, the first beat of the bar is often emphasised, while reggae rhythms are characterised by a heavier third beat. There are also physical limitations on how hard you can strike a drum: beats played in quick succession will tend to be quiet, since you can’t raise the sticks as high, or get so much travel with the bass drum pedal, between hits.
Also, don’t ignore dynamics within the song. In dance music, the drums are often compressed to the point where they are totally even in volume throughout, and any dynamic changes are effected by simply dropping out parts of the rhythm. Real drummers, however, use crescendos and other dynamic effects to add feel to a track; often, for instance, they will build up the volume going into a chorus. For the best overall effect, use a combination of heavily compressed core hits and more dynamic percussion hits and patterns.

39. Actually play your rhythm parts rather than always programming them

It’s one thing to have the feel of a pattern in your mind: however, it’s much harder to analyse the slight timing variations that produce that feel. The best way to capture ‘feel’, therefore, is to play the parts into your sequencer, from a keyboard or other controller, in real time. Start with the two most important – usually the kick and snare – in a single pass. Playing the drums well is, like most instruments, difficult and takes some expertise, but it’s not too hard to bash out a basic rhythm with two fingers on MIDI pads or a keyboard, and doing so makes it much easier to capture the elusive ‘feel’ of a real drum part. And of course the beauty of sequencing is that you can correct any mistakes afterwards.
If you’re not sure what sort of feel your drum part should have, or you can’t seem to get it right by just recording to a click track, remember that you don’t have to record the drums first. If your song centres around a particular piano or bass riff, for instance, you could try recording that into your sequencer first and add the drums later. Being able to hear the important instrumental parts is very useful for deciding what kind of rhythm will or won’t work.
If you do need to edit the patterns you’ve entered, avoid snap to grid or similar functions. It’s all too easy to end up not only correcting mistakes, but also the timing variations that are responsible for the ‘feel’ of the part. Though editing can be used to remedy mistakes or really sloppy timing, there’s little point in painstakingly bashing out your rhythms in real time if you’re then going to quantise away all the variations. If you must quantise, leave a fairly wide margin so that only really late or early beats are corrected.
Bear in mind that a lot of real drummers and grooves actually depend on consistent deviations from theoretically accurate timing. Sometimes this is quite obvious, as in the case of heavy syncopation or ‘swing’, which imposes a triplet feel on a four-beat rhythm, but it can be much more subtle. For instance, playing slightly ahead of the beat, particularly on the first and third beats of a four-beat bar, is a common device used to add urgency to a rhythm. In other genres like the blues, by contrast, drummers sometimes deliberately delay the ‘off’ beats to create a laid-back feel.

40. Special Effect Reverb: Use Sparingly And With Variety

Bear in mind that the impact of any special effect diminishes with familiarity, so it may be counterproductive to leave it in the mix for too long: it can be much more effective and lively to punch such an effect in and out at key moments in the arrangement or for certain sections.
Leading on from this, it’s worth also giving some dynamic changes and variations to what are often left as static effect sends like reverb and delay. These don’t have to be set at an optimum level and just left – effects can also be ‘played’ and respond to what’s going on at each moment of the track, almost like musical parts in their own right. Experiment with automating reverb decay and pre-delay times, and delay feedback amounts to add punctuation or variation at certain points in the track. This is something people like Karlheinz Stockhausen and Pierre Schaeffer were doing back in the 1950s (always worth checking out if you don’t know about Musique Concrete), when they didn’t have a lot else to play with.

41. Fake Ambience Mics

Synth and drum machine sounds are usually made using samples of each instrument in isolation. Recording a real drumkit is a different matter, however; overhead or room mics are always used (usually in conjunction with close mics on individual drums) to pick up not only cymbals and toms, but the sound of the whole kit, along with a certain amount of room ambience. Programmed drum parts in their raw state can sound sterile and disjointed by comparison, because they lack this element. You can get around this by setting up a fake ‘room mic’ reverb channel, with all of the drum parts routed to a particularly spacious reverb. Bring this group up underneath the main drums and loops for more ambience – it won’t generally detract from the ‘electronic’-ness and power of the drums, but will just put them in a ‘real’ place, that can glue them with the rest of the track.

42. Have a Reverb Strategy

When you have the right combination of reverbs on the parts of your mix, it adds a whole other level of natural depth, power and focus. This is generally achieved with cumulative small amounts of several reverbs applied to different instruments and parts, so it’s important to understand and consider whether your overall use of reverb will give you the level of ‘liveness’ or atmosphere that you’re after. Experiment with different depths and styles of reverb until you find something that sounds right.
Also check out The Ultimate Guide to Reverb in the ebook store.
Ebook Store 300x250 ad

43. Make sure you have a great musical foundation to build on, before getting carried away with FX and sound design

Don’t focus too much at first on how the record’s going to sound, production-wise, at the end of the day. Many people have a rather rigid vision in their head and struggle with the initial sounds, when it might be better to just get the parts down and make sure the song is working musically first: let sound design, effects and mixing come later. Then, once you know it works, you can dress it up in any fashion you like.
It can help here to have a basic track template setup in your DAW, with a set of tried-and-tested synth patches and drum sounds already loaded and ready to go. This way you’re not going to get distracted with finding the right sounds, but you will be able to get the melodies and musical elements sounding good as soon as you come up with them. Using these familiar sounds, you can quickly build up the bare bones of an arrangement and test your ideas, and then as the grooves and chord progressions begin to emerge, you gradually replace the original sounds with new, stronger or more finetuned and appropriate versions.

44. Try Different Approaches To Writing And Arranging

If you are producing music on a computer for long periods of time, it’s easy to begin to feel stagnated and loose creativity. Changing your working method is one way to approach music from a slightly different angle. This break from monotony usually results in flashes of inspiration, and of course the development of new tricks and techniques. Here are some ideas:
The Loop Method
With 8-16 bars looped in your DAW, write a melody or drum pattern, and then add other instruments based on this core part one at a time as you play back the looped section. Once you have built up enough elements that it feels like the climax of a track, copy and paste the enitre loop over the length of a track and start muting parts to create variations in the arrangement.
The Sample Method
Gather a small selection of samples – either your own recordings or from various sample collections – and build a complete track using just those samples. You’ll find the restriction of using only those sound sources refreshing and challenging, and usually you come up with cool stuff that you wouldn’t otherwise have created given limitless options.
The Piano Method
Try writing a complete electronic or club-style track using just a piano sound. Once you have a really good chord progression and melody that sound great even on piano, only then is it time to switch out the piano channels for synths, drums and other instruments.
It’s often tempting to write sub-par music and then spend ages making it better with additional effects, programming and processing. Forcing yourself to start with a sure musical footing for a track means that the effects don’t end up taking over, and the results are more likely to have been worth the effort.
The Live Jam Method
Start with a couple of basic drum and bass loops, copied and sequenced enough times that they’ll play continuously for at least a couple of minutes without looping.
Find a synth patch or other instrument you like, set the DAW to record and simply play spontaneously over this backing track until you stumble onto a melody or chord sequence you like. When you’ve made a recorded pass or two, go back over the recording and pick out any bits that seem to have some potential: from here you can either repeat the whole process but this time focusing on developing the potential part, or you can begin layering up another sound on top in the same way.
Try and stay away from extra processing or effects at first, as the general idea is to concentrate solely on playing and improvisation, rather than already thinking about mixing or programming: this keeps the music kinetic and flowing, and you can often come up with some quite different ideas from how your more considered approaches might sound.
The ‘Author’ Method
Most professional authors and other writers make a point of writing a certain number of words a day. You can do the same with your music writing, arranging, production and mixing. This is more difficult than it sounds, but if you can stick with it, it’s great for your self-discipline muscle, not to mention your creativity.
The Immersion Music Method: Twenty Songs In One Day
See how many new tracks you can start from scratch and complete in a single day. This does wonders for unblocking your creative juices and really forcing you to lose those perfectionist tendencies that keep you from finishing so many good ideas.

45. Five Parts Or Less At Any One Time: Less Is More

If you listen to a lot of good arrangements in any style, it soon becomes apparent that most of them don’t contain huge numbers of parts. Five elements at one time – counting the drums as one – is generally the most you’ll hear and this rule seems to extend across style boundaries. Laying on more and more parts may be a waste of time, as there’s only so much the brain can follow before the sound turns into a mush and the impact of the individual parts is lost.
However, having said that…

46. Layering & Doubling Parts For Added Interest, Punch And Character

Five parts doesn’t necessarily mean only five instruments, as lead and drum sounds in particular can be given additional punch, character and sonic variation by being made up of several carefully chosen individual elements, that while all occupying their own frequency range, each contribute to a composite that is perceived in the end as a single musical part. In the same way that you might add a flute to an oboe part in a orchestral composition because it lends delicacy, lightness and accent to the deeper warmth of the oboe, so you might combine a deep sine or square wave bass synth with a higher pitched distorted saw synth for extra mid-range bite and definition. Done correctly, the two layers come across as being one huge, aggressive bassline.

47. Quick Tips For Convincing Orchestral Parts

Writing simple but convincing MIDI orchestral parts is often a case of just thinking it through logically, and needn’t be so complicated: think of sustaining instruments like strings and horn sections taking the role of synth pads, and melodic instruments like flutes, clarinets and trumpets each having a timbre and function in the way that different synth patches evoke different moods and ‘colours’. To understand what kind of articulations and dynamics are appropriate for each instrument, listen to reference tracks – film soundtracks are a good place to start, as theyoften have very sparse sections and can be more easily picked apart than very dense Classical orchestrations.
Don’t overdo it
If you’re looking to make the most convincing, realistic orchestral sounds possible, take time to consider the ensemble size for the piece you’re composing. It’s easy to slip into the mindset of ‘bigger is better’, but smaller, more intimate instrument groups often achieve more powerful results.
Explore the different articulation and modulation options
Similarly, orchestral instruments don’t spend their whole time playing smooth, legato phrases. There’s a world of articulation possibilities there, with spiky, shimmery, marked, dynamically shifting and bendy notes used just as frequently as good old ‘sustain’. Try out the staccato, tremolo, marcato, crescendo and portamento articulations (to give names to these options) to get a handle on your options.
Creating depth: strategise arranging ensemble instruments
Don’t just let your samples arrange themselves in the mix; think it through. If you’re using a single string section patch, set it up four times, copy the part to four MIDI channels and thin each one out, so that one instrument group resides on each channel, before panning them individually. Think about the spatial depth you’re after, too, and set up appropriate reverbs to create it.

48. Guide The Listeners Attention From Sound To Sound

While it’s always good to give a lead vocal or instrument space in the mix, don’t forget that you can punctuate the gaps in these parts with flourishes and effects from other instruments and parts. Remember that at every moment of the track the listener wants to be given a focal point to guide them through the different sections: it’s your job to pass their attention from one sound to the next, and the better and more fluidly you can do this the more alive and exciting your tracks will appear.

49. Use Different Chord Inversions For Instant Depth & Sophistication

When writing and arranging chord progressions, instead of using the same chord shape and simply moving it up and down the keyboard, unchanged in shape, try using different inversions. If the chords you play are (C) (F) (G), rather than playing the notes in the order C E G / F A C / G B D, where the fifth note of the chord stays in the same position, try playing C E G / C F A / B D G. It can be surprising how much more interesting simple progressions can become with some simple chord shape-shifting.
You can incorporate the main bass part in this too, getting maximum harmonic value out of your bassline by using notes from within the chord other than the usual root note.

50. Music Theory For Non-Musicians: Learn A Bit Of Music Theory

Even a small amount of music theory knowledge can go a very long way in improving the arrangements and voicings of your electronic projects. It’s not dull or scientific, and learning music theory will mean you’ll find it easier to analyse what is and what isn’t working in your arrangement.
One of the great things about knowing some theory is that you can fall back on technique to get things flowing when pure inspiration is running dry – so your productivity will improve along with your understanding.

quarta-feira, 14 de agosto de 2013


http://roberthenke.com/interviews/mastering.html

Between 1996 and 1998 I worked as mastering engineer and vinyl cutter at Dubplates & Mastering, a company founded by Basic Channel in 1995. Shortly before I left, Rashad Becker joined the team. Over the years he became one of the most inspired and skilled mastering people out there, with an impressive customer list. While still working for Dubplates & Mastering, he now runs his own studio in Berlin Kreuzberg, where he's doing CD mastering and mixing. The following talk took place during a rainy summer day 2008 in his studio.


Robert Henke, July 15 2008Rashad, what is mastering?
Rashad Becker: Mastering means finishing a piece of music or any auditive work for a certain purpose. That purpose can be bound to free artistic ideas, it can also be related to, or referring to specific media, or it can be related to a specific purpose, like for example a certain speaker set up, or even a specific room. Radio broadcast would be also a specific condition.Mastering is also the strictly technical process of producing a master. Which can be a lacquer for vinyl production, or a CD or whatever medium, but there is a finished product at the end of the day, which is the master from which duplication is launched.
But from an artistic point of view mastering also is approaching someone's music in a state which should be as close as possible to the vision or intention of the artist, and evaluate how much of this aim is achieved and give it the necessary help. The changes applied can be very subtle or sometimes very drastic.


Mastering became quite a fashion word, everyone is doing mastering now, everyone has mastering tools, but there are also those 'mastering gurus' and therefore mastering is located mentally in between being something very obvious and accessible and being a very secret knowledge. It seems a lot of people are pretty confused by that.
I think this development is owing to the fact that somehow some stages have been skipped from the audio production process. In the classic structure of building up musical pieces, there would be composition, in one way or another, and then afterwards recording, and at that point you might already have a producer by your side which is some outer world influence, then you would give it to trusted hands for mixing, and finally the mastering would just be paying specific attention to each piece and then try to round it all up, so that the individual pieces work together.Nowadays, many times the music comes direct out of the stage of composing, which is often strongly related to the mixing process already, or composition and mixing has been merged into one thing, and then the first outer-world process is the mastering. So there is a heap of projections: if music sounds good people blame the mastering, if music does not sound good people blame the mastering. The importance or significance of the mastering process has been upgraded a lot because it has to deliver everything which was originally related to other steps in the production process. Things like having an outside producer or somebody else to take care of details in regards to the big picture.


Became the role of the mastering especially for those producers who have this classical one-man home recording approach more important, because there is no other external person involved prior to the final step?
Yes, but there is another reason why people became more interested in mastering. In the earlier days people where first referring to amazing musicand much less to aspects of production. Nowadays music production became more and more an element of creating music and 'good production' is often seen as being more important than a musical idea. People are overwhelmed by the possibilities and by the results they can achieve with very little effort, because the tools they have at hand give them overwhelming results with very little knowledge.The initiative for making music has been shifted to the production side and so did the perception of the process. The colour of the composition, musical inspiration and decisions, all these aspects have been shrunken a little bit perceptional in favour of the production and that's also why mastering is seen now as having such a musical impact.


Can you give me an explanation of the mastering session as a process?
Mastering is finishing a musical piece post mix towards the release of that piece.So what happens is: people come to me with their music, we talk about the format, because from the start on you have to consider what format do you treat the music for, and as a first step I arrange the pieces in the final playing order.
Then the next step is basically listening to the music and finding out what intention is prominent in the music, what is the basic... um.. sculpture or basic message or basic groove or whatever it is, that carries the piece, and to judge a) how much of that intention is achieved and b) how much of my personal feeling for how it should be is achieved?confidence
Of course the artists intention is prior, but very often mastering is about confidence and also people not wanting to be in charge anymore for what the result will turn out to be. People want to trust.
Technically speaking it is a very little thing. Like with all audio treatment you refer to frequencies, to amplitudes, and to phase relations, and these are the three parameters you can work on. For that purpose you utilise equalisers, filters, compressors... and that's it.


How does your signal chain look like? What is in it?
Well, I've been very much hooked up by the idea of mid/side processing. That means the stereo signal is split into two channels which are not left-right, but where one channel is the sum channel and one channel represents thedifference. This means you have one channel which carries the signals which are the same on both speakers and one channel which holds all the information that differs form one speaker towards the other.So the set-up is like a left-right set-up physically, but the former left channel carries the mid signal, and the former right channel carries the side signal. Decoding signals like this allows for a very precise control over the stereo image during the mastering process.
I think the most important tool probably is the parametric equaliser so I have a couple of bands of parametric equalisation here. Followed typically by a tube compressor, then followed up by another filter section which is a passive filter designed for the low range, and two active bands for the higher mid range and the high range. Then there is another stage of transistor based compression.Optionally another stage of EQ is available which I classically use very narrowly and then there is the direction mixer which decodes the signal back to left-right and gives the opportunity to make final corrections in the stereo field, followed by a brick wall limiter. And after that there is the analogue to digital conversion. So my signal chain in this room is exclusively analogue, framed by the DA / AD converters.


There is almost an infinite amount of possible equipment out there which more or less does the same things. How did you decide about which tools to get when you decided to build your room? What drove your decision to use this or that product?
That's a complicated question! There are a lot of things to take into account, but at the end of the day it comes basically down to taste. The products I have selected are all very specific. None of them are really neutral, except for maybe some of my filters.They all have a pretty decisive character and I think that's for me mostly the point. When judging audio art one of the prior parameters for achievement is decisiveness.
So I don't have a strong feeling for 'this sounds right or this sounds wrong' - or this feeling is always bound to: does it sound decisive or does it sound like someone was twiddling around and achieved something and was just happy? Does it sounds like somebody made a decision to have it sound like exactly this? This is for me a very, very important quality.I tend to say that the science of the machines I have chosen is, that they all have a very clear vision of what they should aim for, what they should help for, what they should add to the signal. And I do appreciate that they are all high end designs, so they can be rather invisible, as well as being able to add a lot of character.
That's why there is such a lot of EQs and compressors in the signal chain, because all of them are used very decently and it sums up.distortion
I forgot to mention the other type of tool I came to like and use very much in a mastering application, which is tube distortion, which I also use in mid/side coding. The input of the distortion is fed from a graphic EQ so I can emphasize and roll off signals which I don't want to be included in the distortion. Sometimes the distortion is rather brutal but mixed in at very very low levels. And sometimes I only apply it to side signal, sometimes only to the mid signal.
I did not expect that distortion could be so useful, I thought is was more a production tool but is has become a very central piece for mastering for me.


At the first glance that sounds like a weird contradiction. Many producers are very anal about sound quality and are so afraid that their equipment alters the sound and that tiny little distortions due to rounding errors in their workstations ruin their work, and and now you tell me that in your mastering process you add distortions?!
The term distortion is of course stigmatised (laughs). I mean distortion is any deviation from the original waveform, adding harmonics is (non-linear) distortion and as soon as you apply any kind of filter you have (linear) distortion.But you can apply the parameter of sound quality to distortion as well. There is low quality distortion and there is high quality distortion and what I can provide here is rather high quality distortion. Here I can add harmonics, in a way that is impossible to achieve with any kind of equaliser or filter alone, because they can only enhance what is already there.
I am not in favour of trying to add colour with an equaliser; most equaliser designs are not really fit for that. Sometimes you need to roll off a lot to get rid of unwanted signals and the mix is totally in the mud and you don't have nice or interesting high frequencies and there is no sense in boosting these parts of the spectrum. So it might sometimes be better to replace it by something else. Adding distortion also can help in definition of spatial parameters, helps broaden the stereo image in a subtle way.


So the distortion adds harmonics which are not present in the original signal but which are related to the original signal and which are applied carefully to make the overall sound more rich?
Richer and with more dynamic. I can apply harmonics, I can apply sub-harmonics, I can emphasize the fundamentals - it depends on the application. I always use the distortion in parallel. The original signal does not get replaced by the distorted signal but gets mixed with the distorted signal, so I have a very precise control over the amount and colour of the distortions.


You are using mostly hardware for your mastering. However there is nowadays an almost infinite number of plug-ins for mastering - what's your opinion about plug-ins?
I don't have too much of an opinion here, because I have too little experience. I have been interested, so I have been scrutinising the options and I did not yet come across anything really satisfying in the plug-in realm.I was eager to have at least a software limiter after the conversion so I don't have to run the converters too hot to achieve nowadays zero margin levels, and I found one plug-in which kind of does the job ... and I was really eager to find something which is great- it doesn't seem to exist actually.
This is not really digital versus analogue topic! In the digital realm there is high end stuff which is in some regards superior to analogue stuff, especially when it comes to the very crucial topic of limiting. Take the Weiss DS1 (digital mastering) compressor for example! I didn't encounter any plug-in yet that comes close to the quality of the DS1.Hmmm.... I don't like to use plug-ins, maybe they just don't have the right interfaces.
[A note, from late October 2008: Rashad finally found a compressor plug in that he likes interface and sound-wise enough to use it frequently R.H.]


With 'the right interface' you mean work ergonomics? Your workspace here is highly ergonomic and it radiates a certain very inviting energy. If I come in here I see there is racks in a semicircle with all this equipment, and it feels like its a very comfortable working space and all functions are nicely spread out. Is the missing haptic part a reason for your difficulties with ... ?
...with integrating plug-ins? I would say so, its hard for me to address them nicely, there are controllers out there which cost of lot a of money and which are probably fit for addressing plug-ins in a decisive manner but another problem with plug-ins is they always give you something to look at, they always give you visual info and you always have to look when working with them.With my hardware I don't ever have to look at it. And this is important for me, I really tend to stop looking, two inches before my eyes, when working with sound. I don't want to see the timeline of the piece, and most plug-ins show some sound related graphical information, which gives you a certain kind of precognition, some kind of pre-expectation towards what is gonna happen next or how the dynamic range has changed.
I am fine with seeing a little bit of gain reduction, some blinking lights. It doesn't even have to be precise, because I wanna hear if the result is right, I don't wanna be tricked into looking and seeing like Whaaa! 2dB of gain reduction, that's gonna be good!Most plug-ins provide too much visual feedback for my taste, which keeps me personally away from mapping the sound to my body, and to my ears - and that's how I master like: that I scrutinise the sound how it hits me. Not necessarily brutally, but how it addresses my body, and if I have to focus on a computer screen and operate with a mouse that is something else, its just a different world.
interface
I have to look and I will look at every parameter if I have a graphical response that shows me that I've notched away 2.73dB or 2.89dB. I will take this information in, whereas when I work with analogue or hardware gear I just don't care at all about this kind of information, I don't get that anal about the values! With pIug-ins I tend to really go far beyond the decimal point and that's just not the right setting, not the right state of mind for me.Same happens with customers, here people sometimes for the first time see their album layout on a computer screen as waveforms, piece after piece, and just from the way it looks to them, they might like it or might not like it, and they judge the proportion of the piece from a graphic perspective, they see different levels, they see that one piece has maybe a much thicker representation than the other one, and suddenly they get the feeling that it might be a weak piece, or definitely too low in volume. Even though before seeing it they felt it had the right prominence.
They come to the mastering place or the mixing studio and I transfer all tracks from their HD recorder into the computer and they suddenly look at their music and start losing trust in the tension of the music and in the narration. They hear it a second time, they see the Boom! coming and suddenly they are really unsure - they ask me: how long is the piece again? And all that considerations which have not been a topic for composing suddenly become very important.This all comes with using computers and this also happens in the mastering stage if you work on a computer screen. You are not independent of these things. Well, I am most certainly influenced by that, and that's why I like to work with hardware. You have the narration in the room from your speakers, and that is it. That's what your are judging.


Hmm.. makes a lot of sense, I feel this sometimes too, that I'm confused by the visual representation and that I think, oh!, this piece is too long or too short, just based on what I see, or oh, this break here is too much ...
Ah, this element element I could repeat. I only have it once here, It would look nice here, ....(laughs)


..a bit more a technical question again - is there a difference between mastering for CD or for vinyl? You hinted that there is a difference when you said at the beginning that it is important to know what the final medium should be, but I'd like to talk about it from a perspective of someone who finished a track and who wants to understand or learn more about mastering.
Mastering is somehow a musical process, so each track should in the first place musically get what it needs and then the tracks should work together nicely.So I do the musical mastering, and afterwards I take care of the technical restrictions of the target medium in a second step. The difference between the CD mastering and the vinyl mastering is that you don't have any limitations on most parameters of the sound expect for the final peak volume on CD, and you have much more physical restrictions which do translate to sonic restrictions, when transferring sound to vinyl. So that's why its a kind of two stage process. In the first step the considerations are, does it feel right? Is the narrative emphasis where it is supposed to be... stuff like this, and then in the second step the question is, will I get this on vinyl like that? No... but, yeah... but no... but yeah, sometimes...
vinyl

Sometimes you have to do musical restrictions to the pieces when mastering explicitly for vinyl. Like you might have to lower the prominence of critical parts of the vocals if you want to make a very loud yet undistorted cut.


Can you tell me with more technical details about the restrictions?
Its not so much real 'restrictions', its alterations of the signal, and you have to consider those. The things that you have to keep in mind is that some geometries of the groove cannot be followed precisely enough by the playback needle. So for example, if you try to cut a very broad and complex high frequency signal very loud, most needles will be overwhelmed by that, they will not be able to follow that recorded modulation precisely, and thereby instead of playing back what's in the record, they move in a different way and this means losing the original information and creating additional distortions instead. A classical example for this are distorted hihats.


Mostly the distorted high frequency signal is enriched with sub-harmonics a lot. You will always get some distortion , from vinyl playback you will get very complex distortions, there is no one-to-one reproduction, its just physically impossible. If you just record the same signal on different spots of the record it will already sound different.The question is: how precise will the needle be able to follow the geometry provided by the groove? The accelerations and the movements of the playback needle can get rather complex, especially if any kind of phase information is present, which leads to highly complex groove shapes that are engraved into the record.


Does this imply that you can cut more complex signals if they are in mono than if they are stereo?
Well in mono they are less complex, so mono signals might cause slightly less problems. But there is a huge myth about that you can only cut bass in mono, that's something which is really resistantly in producer's heads, its absolutely not true!I have been cutting several thousand of vinyls and I really have to think hard about when ever I had to cripple a stereo bass signal beyond musical recognition because it wasn't translatable to vinyl. That might be three cases, in all that years.
People should not bother about that, they should make the music the way they feel it should sound like!!!!99% of problems related to phase can be corrected in the mastering room effortlessly without making a musical disaster out of the piece. With most phase adjustments that need to be done for vinyl, you can nicely live, and I never experienced somebody who was really shocked or totally unhappy with the result. Of course in the high days of IDM there were a couple of pieces that had 180 degrees out of phase full level 50 Hz sine waves and such, and that gives you problems...
But that is so much the exception that it is not in balance that every producer takes this so strongly into account which just keeps him away from making music. People should focus on sculpting colours the way they feel it should be, and not think about the post-production.People should not make music for post-production.


What are the most common mistakes of your customers? What are things people do because they are inexperienced, and which makes your life harder, or the result musically miserable?
If you talk about real mistakes, I'd say most mistakes are really related tolimiting. Second most mistakes are related to compression, and that's about it. Mistakes - there are a lot of things I have to cope with, which derive from being uneducated or inexperienced, like for example people keep sculpting their sound by boosting frequencies if they feel an element is not prominent enough in the mix. Lets boost it! If it has not enough bass or not enough high end - lets boost!!!Instead I try to educate my customers to think the other way round: Scrutinise every signal for consistency, check for what disturbs it, and try to remove that, and not primarily check the signal for what's too little...
I always think negative. I know this is much less fun actually, but the results will be much more consistent and also louder. People try to achieve loudness by saturating media and that's just the wrong way, its the other way round! Saturation can be done at the very very end. If you saturate your medium from step one on, you will have music which will have a constant high level but will not sound loud.The basic mistake is that people compress or limit without a musical vision.
They compress or limit because they feel it should be louder, and they do not do proper AB comparisons ... that's the thing you have to learn - making correct AB comparisons. Its absolutely not easy and it takes several years of practice.


Proper AB comparison means that you listen to the your music on your workstation with the limiter and compressor versus the unlimited uncompressed signal and you make sure that the volume between the compressed and uncompressed signal is in a relationship so that you are not tricked by the fact that one is louder?
Yes, but it is more complex than that. Briefly, you should always do different stages of comparison, you should compare whilst not looking at any meter, you pick one element, which might be the most prominent or most important one, or even the least prominent or the least important one, you don't look at any meters and set both signals to a volume so that this element has thesame prominence in both versions. Be very careful about that, if it really has same prominence, and not just closely the same. Then see how the rest of the track wraps around this element in the uncompressed version and in the compressed version. Now look at the meters and set both versions to the same peak level and compare, most of the time compressed signal will probably win. If you on the other hand set them both to similar RMS or average level and compare, there is a good chance the uncompressed version will win in that case.


If you compare looking at the average level, the uncompressed version will sound more lively, and more punchy! It is hard to speak in general terms here, but I think that a certain amount of generalisation is rather fair, because compression is a high art and its very easy to be satisfied by the results compressors give you, without the results being really good. You can easily be fooled by that perceived boost in loudness if you do not compare correctly.


So should people compress at all?
Well, I always tell my customers: If you use compression for musical matters, and never mind what compression's supposed to be - forget about all that.. if you use the compressor and theresult is something which is just evidently musically what you wanted to achieve, of course, go for it! But do not compress, just because you think it has to be compressed. I think that's it as a rule of thumb.When it comes to limiting, whenever you have the chance to go to a mastering room, don't do any limiting at all! Sometimes it helps on a single track to get rid of certain spikes, but don't do it on the sum. Also be careful or at least think twice before using compression in the sum.
limiting
Don't use maximisers. Never ever. Except if you need something to sound as loud as possible on TV. Maximisers are just not a tool to use in a musical process. A mastering engineer will not have the chance to do anything with the music anymore if it has been maximised already. The track is flat, dead and sealed, with no access to details.


I understand your approach to use hardware for all the reasons you mentioned, but assuming someone wants to do mastering by themselves and all they have is a laptop, can serious mastering be done entirely in software these days?
Good question. I'm probably not the most competent person top answer that question, but from what I've seen on the market I am not entirely convinced.But a much more important point here is, that this often implies the question if a person can master their own music by themselves. Its a bit a closed circuit in thinking. One of the most evident legitimacies for the mastering process is, that some one else you can trust finishes your music.
Software might be able to replace my racks of hardware, but it cannot replace the engineer.


Should people still attempt to master stuff themselves, or would you say that this is something one should never touch a at all?
As I said, an important part of the mastering process is that it is somebody else does it, even if your are the mixing engineer and the recording engineer and you have forty years of experience. Ideally the mastering should be done by someone else. But it should be somebody else you are in touch with, someone you know, and you should attend the mastering session. That's the ideal situation. But of course people who master themselves are mostly not control freaks but just cannot afford to have the mastering done outside their home studio.If you have to master by yourself, do not attempt to do so in the mix. Mix from a musical perspective, do not mix into a limiter or compressor, and carry the finished mix to twenty places to listen to it in different conditions, and let some time pass by.
And then do the mastering. The mastering should be a totally separate process.


What advice wold you give to someone who wants to buy mastering equipment?
First, I would ask some questions in return, what do you want to buy for? What music are you treating,... hmmm.. if there are no budget limits.......tricky question. What you need is a mastering console where you can easily compare and access signals, because mastering is all about comparison. If you cannot compare properly you cannot master properly. So that part should be the centrepiece, and the starting point of your considerations should be the signal flow, and how to control it.
The mastering desk is also very important because this will be one piece of equipment that will always be in the signal chain and everything which is remarkable about it will be remarkable on every piece of music which goes out of your studio.You would need some decent parametric EQs, and I would suggest getting one or two colourful broader EQs. If you go for equipment that has lots of character, you have to be careful, because if it is too recognisable, all your masters will sound the same. It should be equipment which is capable of giving character but which is also capable of being quite neutral.
dynamic
Im turning my back on multi-band compressors recently. I have been a fan for some years but the more I work with them the less happy I am. It is good to have at least one frequency selective compressor, especially for the bass range, but the classical multi-band designs have three ore more bands and you get more trouble than benefit from that. But to have a frequency selective compressor is very handy, you can use for de-essing, you can use it to control the low bass etc...


Tell me about listening volume!
It has to change all the time!!! Hearing is not linear, that means if you change the level your perception changes, so if you listen to a piece at different levels the perceived relation between frequencies will change.Also you have to ask yourself, will this be a piece of music that will mostly be listened to very loud, or is it music which will be listened to normally in a home listening environment? That should change your way of approaching the piece and how you are looking at it in regards of sonic consistency. Not the same results will be consistent in both scenarios. Of course people will also listen to club music at low volume at home, but if you have a reference it should be taken into account.
And besides that, I find it hard to judge compression at normal listening volume. At normal listening volume its easy to make wrong judgements about compression. At very very low levels compression mistakes become very evident and at high levels also. So the first thing I do is to listen to a track at a very very low level, I also do AB comparisons often at the limit of the capability of hearing. Besides that, the longer you work on a thing, the lazier you get, so you have to really discipline yourself to change the listening levels, but it should always change. When I work I always have one hand at the volume control. One should change the level two times a minute! (laughs).The mastering engineer Bob Katz tries to establish a fixed listening level for mastering, similar to the fixed level approach for mixing movies for cinema, where it really makes sense. But I am not very confident about this when mastering music...


How important is mastering?
The answer is: it depends on mastered by whom...(laughs). How much a record can improve from mastering is related not to the quality but to thecharacter of the music. Not all music really is timbre music, not all music really is functional music. There are a certain not too small genres of music where I would even be tempted to say its not so important how it sounds, it might still be brilliant music! Of course, it can benefit from sounding good in a car or other music-hating environments in which people like to listen to music nowadays: On your mobile phone, on your computer, in your agency, at Starbucks and wherever.... But: there is music where the sound of the music might not be the crucial element.And then of course it depends on how close the sound is to what you wanted to achieve. Actually, in contradiction to all the expectations of the clients, the closer the sound already is to what it is supposed to be, the harder it is to master it. The more repair it needs, the easier it gets. Things that sound unachieved ... every little help will give a lot. But if it sounds already really, really achieved, and someone sits there and says: "I want you to get that extra notch, I want you to add your character" or something like that, this is sometimes much more work and much harder to achieve. If customers come with an album, and say "it really sounds very good already, it shouldn't be a lot of work", I'm getting pretty scared actually.


I'd like to talk about objectivity in mastering. It sounds like its a very personal process, and that your role is far beyond fixing technical things. Given this I assume that mastering is not objective at all - you are adding your personal filter to the music - what are your thoughts on this?
I think it hardly can be objective at all. In no regard. There are elements to the mastering which are outside of your own consideration, but still dependent on your own experience. For example, if you master an album, it is important that you set the levels in a manner that the listener will not have to change the level whilst enjoying the album. I always advise my clients to listen to the whole album once, on the borderline to disturbing their neighbours, and see if there is any track where you would immediately want to lower the levels. Then listen to the whole album again at the very low end of attention or perception, and see if there is any track where you spontaneously want to pump it up. So you could say that's some objective measurement, but at the end of the day it still depends on your experience and the focus you have whilst listening to the music.objectivity
Some might focus on the voice, and others might focus on the kick-drum. And so their perception of an even level throughout the album might be different. It depends on the complexity of the music and your selection form that complexity, so even these parameters can't really be objective. You could want that it sounds good in a club, and you could think that is objective, but then again what is 'sound good'? You know, even with the same piece, different people might select different elements of prominence. Some are totally happy with the snare carrying the track, while others are really intrigued by how shy this one element in the background is in relation to all the other elements in the track. Objectively you can say that this piece will be more dependent on spatial parameters than that piece, because the frequency-distribution is more even, so it will be not as much affected by any room resonance as the other one which has one very strong and prominent resonance in that tonal element around 120Hz, and whenever a room matches this, we'll get into trouble. You could say that there's an objective to aim for an even distribution of frequencies, but then again, that might not be musically right. Because some song might need that totally exaggerated low mid peak which does not sound even at all, and then it would be a miss-achievement of the mastering if it would attempt to get rid of it completely.You would say objectively speaking this or that will not sound good on all hi-fi systems. I don't think that this should be the only reference for mastering - to make music sound reliably represented on all sound systems. If that blurs the character of the music beyond the intentionof the artist, then I say its a miss-achievement.
Though my mastering approach is probably very much dependent on my personal experience, I still feel like my mastering efforts are very much apart from taste. I don't feel like: "I really like that or I really don't like that" - I always see the piece as an entity outside of me. I feel what is right for the piece or what is wrong for the piece, and customers will have to rely on that. Of course, I will discuss what I feel, but it will be my personal judgement at the end of the day. Does the music address me in a way I can receive it? Yes or no? Does it it address me in a way I like to receive it? Yes or No? That's the questions, and that needs to be subjective.


Do you need to like the music you master?
No.
I have to say I am rarely troubled by music, I am rather troubled by bad lyrics. So if something keeps me from mastering, or if I suffer from mastering, then it's because of the lyrics. That is rarely the case, but it happens. I don't even have to be intrigued by the music, independent of that, I can sense if it feels right for me or wrong.


Are there specific types of music you really enjoy mastering, or other types you really do not enjoy?
Hmm ... (after a long pause) ...I couldn't really put my finger on that. I would say no. There is of course music I like more, and I might enjoy working on it more, but then again I really try to keep my culture and my identity apart from my job. Sometimes, I'm really happy to work on music I can absolutely not relate to, it gives me also pleasure. I feel like I'm doing my job, and it doesn't feel l like I'm living my life. Sometimes there is music and I can strongly culturally relate to it, and then I also enjoy it, because I feel like I am having a good day. But I am cautious not to have a good day when it's a good working day. I want to be very cautious about that. But naturally I enjoy that I am not bombed with music that tortures me, which is rarely the case. I think it comes from the context which I emerged from. It kind of sorts itself out, I never actively reject or pick a project. The projects which are carried to me are to ninety-nine percent projects I can relate to anyway. Then everything else is dependent on the day. I mean stupid things like some day you are really up for some bass, and some day you really are not up for bass...I don't take much pleasure from music that's really greyish. And sometimes if there's a long row of tracks coming in which all have the same greyish type of consistency I get a bit wasted. It's hard for me then to still feel if it's right or wrong, because it just generally feels unpleasant.


Would you say there is a specific Berlin sound in mastering?
Most certainly there is a perception of that. May be a myth, I can't confirm if its a myth or not. People tend to say, well that sounds like English mastering, that sound like Detroit, that sounds pretty much Berlin, but how could anybody verify if it is really the mastering which makes it comparable? I know I can observe sonic fashions and vogues in the music which is carried to me. Not necessarily stylistically but definitely sonically. And also I can say there are vogues if I look at my own oeuvre, my own mastering back catalog, I can see that in some years I had a certain focus on specific elements of sound. Spectrally but also spatially, and I can see changes, see that this focus transforms a bit over time, and that's probably the case for every mastering studio and engineer. But as I said before, it is hardly verifiable. Of course every studio has a slightly different palette of gear and signal path, and this might inevitably contribute a bit to a specific tone. But that is quite theoretical.


What are your thoughts about volume?
It's a shame. It's a pity, I really don't know where this is leading to, this general development of aiming for maximum loudness. Do we speak of loudness or of volume?


Both!
Volume is a pain in the ass, the listening volumes everywhere... it's gross. But the hunt for loudness is a real pity. It makes music more and more comparable, it removes a lot ofnarration, it removes a lot of information, both from the music making process and from the music perception!By producing music that's always aiming for maximum loudness you don't give people good reasons anymore to properly listen to the music. And that will retroactively shape the reasons for making music, and that will lead to a situation where all music is kind of exchangeable.
And that's a real pity, I reckon. I try with my mastering to give people a reason for not only listen to their music on their PowerBook speakers! Clients do tell me that it needs to sound good on PowerBook speakers. When all music is made in that manner, is made to fit the technique the music is played back with, then all music will be shaped from the same wood after a couple of years.And I can understand that people don't take the effort anymore to get proper hi-fi systems,because they're just not given the reasons to do so anymore. I think the general evaluation of musical products suffers from that. Like also the total availability; you don't have to go searching for music that you're interested in anymore. Music became even more push media, it's notmusic on demand anymore.
loudness
The topic of loudness: There's music which needs to have loudness - there's a certain idiom in music where you always have the contrast of quiet parts and blasts and dramaturgical there's a huge potential in loudness of course. But if you make all music always loud, steady-state, you lose that potential. Besides from the physical effects it has of tiring your ears. You know about transients and you how they shape your cognition of sound. Transients are a phenomena or an aspect of music which are really vanishing from music. More or less, there are no transients included in music any more, and this is taking away so much of musical information.


process
I mean the usage of the ears became rather degenerated, or it is not developed to the standard the ear potentially offers. People use their ears as bad eyes. They don't train their listening, they don't question the ways by which reality is represented by their ears. And this is all related. I think if music today was more as it was some two decades ago; still elaborate on narrative dynamics, this would generally also educate people more in listening. Just really everyday listening, not necessarily musical listening.I'm not willing to take part in that race for loudness anymore, because it is so damn redundant at the end of the day. Each amplifier has a volume knob.
I have often heard "Well, you need to pump up the master a little bit more because the mp3 player don't give enough level on the headphones." I don't know if that's really the case because I've never used an mp3 player but it would be disgusting if it was the case, but then again what damn levels are people listening to on headphones? This is really making me feel sick! And I don't want be responsible for that. If it's really the case that current mp3 players don't have headphone amplifiers strong enough to cover up all the noise from the city, then they will have them in half a year! I don't know if it should be the ideal aim of mastering to support music-hostile environments.


(after long silence:) This would be a perfect end for this interview. Maybe one last question: How did you become a mastering engineer?
My background is a social track actually, rather than a professional track. I've been making music since I was a child, and that emerged into very different kinds of cultures and very different kinds of environments. In the 1980s I've been doing tape stuff quite a lot, and I started to record other people when I was sixteen. Then I went into different things - I was at an art school, and then I started working as a sound engineer again on musical projects. Later I worked as a sound engineer in theaters, then sound design for theaters, and theatre music. Then I started editing movies. While doing this, I was asked to come to Dubplates ( Dubplates&Mastering ) to do mastering. I didn't have any real experience up to that point, and for me it was really a social thing, because I felt socially close to that set-up at Paul Linke Ufer with the Hardwax record store and all those people involved, and I felt culturally close to the sound I was relating to this. So I thought: Yeah!, let's do that for a year or something. I always liked to work on a project basis, where you dig into something for six weeks and then it goes away! But that's not the case with mastering, it's just always something on your plate.I knew that, I could smell that in the very beginning - so I thought I'd do that for a year. It wasn't like mastering was something I always wanted to do, that's really not the case. I started mastering without ever really having watched anybody doing it. Also when I started at Dubplates, most engineers were leaving as you know; you started being involved with Ableton, Andi wanted to make more music, and so I had maybe two or three sessions where I learned how to handle the vinyl cutting machine, and then everything just fell into place somehow. I just started doing it. I don't even know if mastering is so much apart from any other sound treatment - you know, the most important thing is that you know what you want, because mastering is about decisions. So you can master any track in twenty-five different fashions, and at the end of the day if you screw around with the track and you think well, that's probably good, let's do it like this, it might be good, but it might also sound like its "probably good".
As I said earlier, for me the achievement in mastering or in sound is that it sounds decisive - that's my idea of 'good'. I always found this kind of easy, I think that probably the only talent I really have - making decisions for other people. I'm not so easy in making decisions on my ownmusic, but I can relate to other peoples material. I can feel safe with the decisions. Of course I also learnt that more by confirming the decisions I made in the outside world, by listening to records I've cut in clubs or something like that. But this is what feels like my qualification: to feel trustworthy on the decisions I make. I've just started doing that, because in all the working scenarios we had since the early nineties, that's the only qualifications that all the people had to have: Take responsibility, not necessarily really being capable of doing something, but taking the responsibility of what you do.So I just started taking it.


“Analog versus digital” – the discussion, it seems, is everywhere. The problem is, many people simply don’t understand what these terms mean. In one 25-minute video – engaging and entertaining to watch straight to the end – the biggest myths all get busted.
In short:
1. 16-bit, 44.1 kHz really is okay for many tasks. (You’re saving that data for the computer and processing rather than your own ears. Hope to talk about this question in more detail soon.)
2. Digital audio doesn’t involve stairstepping.
3. Digital signals can store and be used to reproduce sound that’s identical to what’s stored in analog form.
“Choosing” between analog and digital, as categories, therefore doesn’t make any sense at all. Now, choosing between individual filters, for instance, or caring about the physical design of electronic instruments, or recognizing that you can screw up a digital or an analog recording – all those things do matter. In fact, they matter so much that obscuring them with misinformation is a very bad thing.
The video is the work of Monty Montgomery at xiph.org. (See also: http://xiph.org/video/vid2.shtmland http://xiph.org/video/) Watch the video, but here’s some discussion:
Digital technology is fairly simple to define. A system using digital signal simply represents information as discrete, sampled values. An analog signal use a continuously-varying electrical signal. Both are means of encoding – neither is the literal sound. A digital system is so-named because those discrete values are akin to counting (hence “digits,” as in counting on your fingers), whereas an analog system uses an electrical signal that is analogous to – though not literally – the original, in that it varies in the way that (for sound) pressure would.
The problem is, people imagine digital signals to be something other than what they are in reality. Ubiquity can breed ignorance. Before digital became so widespread, recording and photography were the first revolution. And perhaps part of the problem is that our society has become so comfortable with those processes – ones that would have seemed magical to someone just over a century ago – that we have failed to distinguish between the representation and the real. But any photograph, any recording is distinct from its original subject.
Analog and digital signals are, like words and numbers, a means of encoding information. Each has limits. In sound, those limits are measured in the dimensions that measure audio, frequency and amplitude.
Digital is no less “real” than analog – and because we listen, in the end, to sound and not the signal, the two can achieve the same results. That means that you don’t have to choose. This is not a religious matter. It’s an implementation detail.
That’s not to say that the difference between analog and digital itself is irrelevant – implementation details can be very important. If you realize that fundamentally, digital and analog signals can create and capture the same sounds, then you turn instead to all of the other potential decisions a designer might make. There are many varieties of different filters, for instance, each with different characteristics. The choice of analog or digital circuitry then becomes dependent on what is most economical, most logical, and what desired sound and usability characteristics a circuit would have.
And as people over-emphasize the difference in signal and fundamental sound characteristics, they also ignore everything else.
The choice of analog control or digital control, for instance, is significant. (In short: without smoothing, digital controls can cause stair-stepping effects, and likewise analog controls may be more limited in terms of features like automation.)
This also puts in sharper relief the other reasons people favor analog technology. Analog’s “warmth,” for instance, may not be a fundamental characteristic of analog signal, but it is characteristic of other tendencies of analog designs. It tells us in part that having more literal data fidelity is not always better. Analog gear also behaves in unique ways, susceptible to variations in climate, age, dirt, and other features – something that can be positive in some cases and negative in others, but that is harder to model in digital form.
Most of all, it’s unfortunate that the term “analog” has substituted for “physical,” particularly outside sound contexts. No hardware is truly “digital.” All of it incorporates some amount of analog circuitry, for one, and it’s also the sum total of many design decisions. The fact that we think of computers as not having physical interfaces is perhaps itself a critique of the physical interaction design of computers – we’re in a way used to the mouse and keyboard that we may forget we’re having a tangible experience at all. The advantage of other designs can be to remind people of that experience.
When people describe the appeal of vinyl records, hardware synths covered in knobs and switches, patch cables and modulars, and other “analog” experiences, what they’re really saying is that they like the physical qualities of these things. And there’s no reason digital technology can’t be involved. Increasingly, it is: music is now very often digitally recorded, mixed, and mastered before being pressed to vinyl, and digital instruments are making use of more knobs and switches and even patch cords, rather than focusing on “virtual” experiences of screens and the like.
Instead of getting stuck in meaningless debates like whether analog or digital is “better,” in other words, we need to have very meaningful debates about design, sound, music, and art. But that sounds, by contrast, like a good use of time.
Spend the 25 minutes – you won’t regret it, even if this stuff is review. Thanks to Chris Randallfor the tip.