terça-feira, 11 de fevereiro de 2014

Becoming a Music Producer: Part 1 – What Does It Mean?

Dubspot contributor Michael Emenau discusses some definitions and misconceptions about the career of the music producer, and sets you on your way to understanding the many paths a producer can take in today’s market. Also check out the rest of our “Becoming a Music Producer” series, part 2 ”Network, Gain Experience and Find Work!” and part 3 ”Developing a Career and Making Money”.
quincy-jones-grammys-awards-1990Acclaimed record producer, arranger and composer Quincy Jones at the 1990 Grammy Awards.
The term “producer” has evolved greatly from the early days of recorded music. Back then, the producer was more of a project manager, gathering various specialists together (engineer, mixer, arranger, composer, musicians) and directing them through the process of making a single or an album. That’s not to say the producer was strictly hands-off. A producer could also be the composer, arranger, or even mixer. What a producer did not do however, was play all the instruments, run to the console to push record, then, after mixing and mastering the album, work on a promotion plan.
Today, it’s become the norm for a producer to be a jack-of-all-trades who writes, arranges, tracks, mixes, masters, and does web design while twittering the entire process. There are clear reasons for this shift: affordable technology has made it possible to create a high-quality product at home, and the demise of the recording industry has shrunk artist support to the point where inexpensive productions are necessary. We all have the opportunity to make whatever we want, and doing it ourselves is often the only option.
jackson_jonesQuincy Jones and Michael Jackson. Jones produced some of Jackson’s greatest albums including Off the Wall, Thriller, and Bad.
WHAT DOES A PRODUCER DO?
Let’s start off with some definitions. (Bear in mind that any time I refer to the “artist,” I mean a band, solo act, singer, rapper, DJ, etc.)
Some potential roles of a producer are:
Engineer – Sitting behind the console, or in front of the computer, recording and mixing tracks
Composer – Writing music for the artist
Arranger – Collaborating with (or working for) an artist to make a recorded version of their composition
Remixer – Taking multitrack stems from a recording and making a new version
Musician – Performing instrumental or vocal parts for the tracks being produced
Mentor – Passively following the direction of an artist and making suggestions
Project Manager – Making sure stuff gets done: hiring, organizing, and shepherding the vision through to a finished product
Therapist (my personal favorite) – Understanding an artist’s vision and talents, and leading them down a path to success
There are many possible roles, and many different roads that all lead to the same place: to create a body of music which is satisfying to the artist and the producer. Whether you are writing, mixing, placing microphones, hanging out all night at a club with MCs, or automating the multi-band subharmonic parallel compression for the kazoo solo, you are producing.
We hope that the public will also love what we create, but it doesn’t always happen that way. Often, the “killer albums” we make end up going nowhere, while our successes come totally by surprise. To be commercially successful, some argue that it’s best to make music in the realm of what is currently popular. Artists may ask you to “make a track that sounds like the newest Skrillex or Chris Brown track.” Try not to get caught up in all this, because:
  1. You will always be one step behind what is actually happening
  2. You need to be proud and believe in whatever you are producing
  3. When you follow your instincts, you will develop your own signature sound (one of the nicest compliments I ever received was “Wow, that really sounds like an MNO track”)
  4. Artists will search you out once you have developed your own sound. I sometimes get gigs based on a track I made ten years ago. Remember, every track you produce is a calling card for the next gig.
Skrillex-GrammyElectronic music producer Skrillex at the 2011 Grammy Awards
The reality is that, as a producer, you need to be in it for the long haul. Your style may change over time, but the core of who you are should be present in every track you make. Find your voice. I know it sounds cliché, but one of the greatest joys of producing music is to see your voice develop, strengthen, and become more distinct over time.
How do you develop the Skills To Be A Producer?
The most important quality of a successful producer is love of music. The curiosity and passion to listen, explore, and experiment with all aspects of music will give you the skills you need, and seriously, if you don’t love music, don’t be a producer. There are much easier ways to make a living.
Learn to play an instrument (or seven). Take some lessons and put in the hours–even a little knowledge of an instrument will go a long way in the studio. Musical instruments are the original building blocks; the more comfortable with them you are, the more depth your productions will have. Virtuosity is not the goal. Strum a simple chord progression on the guitar, play simple melodies and chords on the piano, and start hitting some drums. Try thumping along on a bass (I learned how to play bass last year and it improved my programming skills immensely). Get a feel for what each of these instruments does, and the groove and flavor they add. These four instruments have been the building blocks of popular music for the last 60 years. Understanding their workings, and you will be able to better communicate with those around you.
“A skill that separates a mediocre producer from an exceptional one is actual musicianship. A producer’s ability to contribute meaningfully to a recording session is directly related to his or her understanding of the craft.” – Evan Williams 
Daft-Punk-by-NabilCelebrated electronic music duo Daft Punk “from sampling disco records to creating disco records” | Photo by Nabil Elderkin with Warren Fu or Wax Poetics.
Listen to as much music as possible. Listening should not be a passive activity; it is your job to have a large palette of sounds and ideas to draw from when making music. When you’re in the studio, listen to the voice in your head that says “try adding a cello like in that Haydn Symphony,” or “add some of that freaky buzzing drum stuff that you heard on that Gnawan ceremonial music.” The results will not always be what you want, but you’ll be moving the process forward, and finding your way towards the perfect sound.
  • Don’t write anything or anyone off. Every genre of music has some validity to it and is worth a listen. If nothing else, figure out why you don’t like it, and what you want to avoid in your own productions.
  • Listen not just to melodies and harmonies, but to the structure of songs. Do they have a verse/chorus/verse approach, or do they seem to go on and on? Often, music that seems to go on aimlessly has some structural element that you are not noticing.
  • Listen to the mix. What sticks out? What makes a song memorable? Dissect the instrumentation, and see what the different elements do to the production.
Become educated with recording software and the recording process.  I recommend you learn one or two programs thoroughly, rather than dabble in multiple platforms. Make the computer your creative musical instrument of choice. I start my projects in Ableton Live because I find it quick to get down ideas, but prefer the mixing workflow in Digital Performer. Fortunately, most plug-ins will work in any host. So, whether I’m in Live, DP, or Pro Tools, I still use the same compressors and reverbs. There is no right or wrong DAW–at this point they all sound great. Just figure out which one most effectively transforms what’s in your head to something the world can hear. Another area, often sorely overlooked, is understanding basic studio techniques. Learn about signal flow, gain staging, microphone placement, and preamps. It’s a lot easier to make a great mix when the original tracks sounds good. Go to school, read every audio magazine, ask questions of every person who seems to know what’s going on. Learn, Learn, Learn!
Get in the game. It is not required that you have all these skills functioning at a high level before you go off and start producing tracks. In fact, producing music will help you see the holes in your knowledge, and will inspire (or force) you to learn more. I came into producing through my experience as a studio musician. I know producers who started out DJing, composing, playing in bands, or writing songs, while others were computer nerds with little musical background. What they all had in common was a desire to make great music.
It takes a long time to get your skills down. There is no guarantee that you’ll produce big hits, but persistence will give you the chance to be heard. Keep trying, keep learning, and keep making music!

Michael Emenau a.k.a. MNO has worked professionally as a musician (vibraphone, percussion, laptop), producer, remixer and arranger for 25 years, playing such diverse genres as, jazz, rock, drum’n’bass, salsa, techno, country, Hindustani, gospel, baroque and orchestral music. He has recorded on over 150 CDs, composed music for eight films, toured internationally, and lived on three continents. Michael was the house studio mallet percussionist for Sony Records (Japan) in the 90s, was a founding member of the award winning “Jazz Mafia” as well as working as a producer/remixer for Six Degrees Records in San Francisco, arranged and produced contemporary multimedia productions of the 16th-century composer Henry Purcell in Paris and is now writing a musical based on the life of Dionysus and dividing his time between Montreal and New York.

segunda-feira, 10 de fevereiro de 2014

11 Ableton Operator Tips and Tricks

11 Ableton Operator tips and tricks

Make the most of Live's excellent FM synth

Frequency modulation (FM) synthesis allows for the creation of a huge array of sounds, ranging from tuneful and harmonic to dissonant and chaotic.
This is all made possible through the interplay between so-called oscillators designated as carriers and modulators. The frequency of one such oscillator - also called an 'operator' in FM terminology - is modulated using another that is also in the audible range, resulting in a more complex waveform.
Even using simple sine waves as the raw waveforms of the operators can result in timbres that are rich in harmonics. Increasing the amplitudes of the modulators will give increasingly harmonic-rich signals.
Taking the template laid down by classic digital FM synths like Yamaha's DX7 and SY77 considerably further, Ableton adapted this concept for their own Operator instrument, which is a €79 add-on for Live, or included as standard with Live Suite.
Combining the concept of FM with both additive and subtractive synthesis (which, curiously, do not cancel each other out), Operator is your gateway to a universe of complex timbres, all dialled in via an interface that is intuitive and simple to, well, operate.
With a solid selection of basic waveform types to choose from and the option to create your own using the waveform editor, you can arrange Operator's four oscillators in several predefined routings - known as 'algorithms', in a nod to the very similar system employed on the DX7 - to synthesise a wide variety of musical and non-musical tones.
Here we offer eleven handy tips and tricks to help you make the most of Operator's huge sound-sculpting capabilities. For loads more on making the most of Operator, check out the March issue of Computer Music (CM201), which is on sale now.

Custom waveforms and sampler

In addition to the simple waveforms available in Operator, you can create custom waveforms using the waveform editor. You can also save these custom waveform for later use as .ams files by right-clicking on the waveform editor and choosing Export AMS. One of the advantages of this feature is that you can drag these AMS files into other Ableton devices such as Sampler for use with their modulation capabilities and other processing functions.

Automate the algorithm

Usefully, Operator lets you map the algorithm selector to a Macro control or a MIDI controller. Changing the algorithm will have a significant impact on the result since it changes the global behaviour of the instrument. Therefore, you can start experimenting with changing the algorithm on the fly - try mapping the algorithm to a MIDI controller or an LFO for far-out results.

Sample And Hold

Operator's LFO can be set to output a range of waveforms, and one of the more interesting available waveforms is Sample And Hold (S&H). This signal uses random values chosen at a rate determined by the LFO, to create sci-fi-style sound effects as well as introduce random, unpredictable modulation to your sound.

Using the Coarse parameter

One of the main controls in Operator's oscillators is their Coarse parameter. Note that Coarse is a frequency multiplier and not an octave selector. This means that the frequency of the oscillator will be multiplied by its Coarse parameter. So if Coarse is at 1, an A4 note will be 440Hz; if the Coarse is at 2, the frequency will be 880Hz (an octave higher: A5); if Coarse is set to 3, the frequency is 1320Hz - E5; and so on.

The fifth oscillator

Typically, Low Frequency Oscillators (LFO) have subsonic frequency values. This means we will only hear their effect and not their actual sound. By setting Operator's LFO range to HIGH, you can push the LFO into the audible range, as for as 12kHz. You can think of Operator's LFO as the fifth oscillator.

Global time control

One of the other useful global controls in Operator is the Time parameter. Using this knob, you can scale all the envelopes' timing up and down. This can be used to change the sound drastically or can be modulated using the LFO for a more dynamic effect.

Built-in waveshaper

There is a built-in waveshaper in Operator's Filter panel. You can select the waveshaping curve via the Shaper menu to access the Drive and Dry/Wet controls.

CPU saving tips

Operator is an optimised native Ableton instrument, and its CPU usage is pretty low. Even so, when using several instances of this instrument, you might need to maximise CPU usage for a better overall performance, such as when performing live. You can do this by disabling the features that are not used, and most of Operator's CPU-intensive features such as Filter and Spread can be disabled.

Anti-aliasing

Digital FM synthesis techniques can result in aliasing artifacts when creating timbres with a lot of high frequency information - sometimes desirable, sometimes not, depending on the patch you're creating. To this end, Operator has a togglable high-quality antialiasing filter in the Global section, as well as the global Tone filter that can be used to curtail runaway treble frequencies as much or as little as you like.

Go negative

Playing with Operator's envelopes, you will notice that some parameters can be set to negative values; for example, you can apply -50% in the Filter Envelope. You can think of it as flipping the envelope upside down, so that a slow attack will cause the filter to gradually fall from its initial position, rather than rising, as with a normal, positive modulation setting.

Feedback

We already know that we can modulate an oscillator's pitch using one or more of the other oscillators, but there is another option: any oscillator that is not being affected by the others can modulate itself. You can control the amount of this modulation by adjusting the Feedback parameter in the envelope section of each oscillator.

quinta-feira, 31 de outubro de 2013

Mythbusters: Subtractive vs. Additive EQ

Posted on October 29th, 2013. Written by Matthew Weiss.
If you’ve been out and about on the internet then you’ve probably read that subtractive EQ is generally better than additive EQ. In other words, it’s better to attenuate than to boost.
And you have probably read all sorts of reasons for this: less phase shift, sounds smoother, more accurate, doesn’t require active gain, etc.
Well, I’m here to tell you that a great deal of that is false.
Let’s start by dispelling a few myths.
Myth #1: Subtractive EQ incurs less phase shift, or less noticeable phase shift
This is untrue. The degree of phase shift is 100% controlled by the amount of cut or boost. In fact “phase shift” is almost synonymous with “equalization.” They are inherently part of the same process.
Now, are the artifacts of said phase shift less noticeable? In objective technical reasoning, no, they are not.
And here’s why: If you exclusively use boosting to create an EQ curve on a source and then recreate the exact same curve using only attenuation, and then level match those two outputs exactly, you will get identical signals.
A simple way to test this is by taking any sound source and a shelf filter. Mult the sound source. On one, use a hi-shelf to boost up some high end. On the other, use a low shelf, set to the same corner frequency with the same slope and attenuated by the same amount. Then boost the output volume of the low-shelfed signal up to match the hi-shelfed signal and flip the phase. They will completely null.
What’s important, is to use an EQ where the parameters match up equally. For example, this will work with the Waves Q EQ, but will not work with the Waves Ren EQ.
What this demonstrates is that the phase shift and artifacts produced by that shift are based on the curve and degree of equalization, not whether the equalization is positive or negative.
Myth #2: Subtractive EQ Sounds Smoother
Ultimately the truth to this is based more on application than reality. It tends to be easier to mix additively – boosting up things you want more of.
The problem with this is that it leads to a lot of compensational boosting. By that I mean boosting up lots of frequency ranges when really we just wanted to hear less of one frequency range. Or we will boost up a frequency because we aren’t hearing enough of it, when in reality there’s something from another instrument that’s getting in the way.
These issues aren’t inherent to additive or subtractive EQ, rather, they stem from using additive EQ when subtractive EQ would be a better approach.
Myth #3: Additive EQ is Less Accurate
This is something I hear a lot, and quite honestly I’m not even sure what it really means.
I believe this myth stems from the idea that it’s better to “cut narrow and boost wide.” In reality you should boost or cut as narrow or wide as needed.
I think it’s easier to over extend the width of an EQ boost because that means more stuff is getting louder. And louder has that instant gratification effect of sounding better. Again, this is a result of application and not inherent to how an EQ works.
Myth #4: Subtractive EQ Doesn’t Require Active Gain
This one is based on the idea that because you are “taking something away” you don’t need to add power to do it. This is really only true in the simplest filter setups.
While it’s true that a simple resistor-capacitor circuit doesn’t need any power, most more complex circuits do. That’s not to say there aren’t complex subtractive circuits that work completely passively — there are a lot. But many EQs, no matter what you are doing, are drawing on active power. It completely depends on the EQ itself.
Lastly, digital EQs don’t use power. There’s no such thing as an “active” digital EQ, outside of plugins that emulate hardware.
Myth #5: Subtractive EQ Frees Up Headroom
This is half true. Subtractive EQ can and often does reduce overall amplitude, but the process is actually not amplitude based. You’re not exactly adjust the level of frequencies – you are adjusting the phase, and then getting a change in level at the band you are adjusting. But that’s not the same as adjusting the signal amplitude. In fact, on occasion you will use subtractive EQ and the result will be a boost to the signal amplitude! I kid you not.
So what’s the difference?
The major difference in subtractive vs. additive EQ is the thought process.
When you are using subtractive EQ, you are thinking “what can I take away to make this better.” Taking something away lends itself toward degrading a sound — so any time you take something away and it improves the sound you pretty much know you are making a good EQ move.
Additive EQ, conversely, is enhancing a signal, which naturally tends to sound better no matter what (particularly if you are doing it in solo mode). The real key to using subtractive or additive EQ is to have a good idea of what you’re trying to accomplish. The “solo” button can be very useful here.
Lets say you want to hear more upper mids in your guitar lead. Solo the guitar — does it sound like it has enough upper mids? If not, then use some additive EQ and boost those mids. If it does sound like it has enough upper midrange in solo, maybe there’s something else in the mix that has too much upper mids like a piano or acoustic guitar. Or maybe you really just want to hear the guitar louder, but when you turn it up the lower mids become overpowering. In these cases, subtractive EQ is going to be more effective.
I hope that clears up the reality of EQ. I have another article that dives deep into equalization here.

terça-feira, 22 de outubro de 2013

http://www.soundonsound.com/sos/feb06/articles/studiosos.htm



Paul White
StudioSOS RajDhamu.s
Photo: Richard Ecclestone
Professional studio design is a very specialised science, with more than a touch of 'black magic' thrown in, but as our Studio SOS visits have demonstrated, it is fairly simple to make a huge improvement to an untreated project-studio room without spending a fortune. However, it's also become apparent how often readers' own attempts at DIY acoustic treatment cause more problems than they solve. So I thought it would make sense this month to have a proper look at the principles behind the acoustic-treatment advice we often give on our Studio SOS visits, so that you can apply them to your own setup.
Room problems can be broken down into two main categories: reflections of mid-range and high frequencies from hard surfaces; and peaks and troughs in the room's low-end response caused by the room's dimensions and the reflectivity of the walls at low frequencies. Both compromise the accuracy of what you believe you are hearing from your monitor speakers, and each has to be dealt with in different ways.

Placing Monitors & Studio Equipment
In an ideal world, what you hear when sitting in your monitoring chair should be mainly the direct sound from the speakers. However, unless you record in an anechoic chamber and cover all your gear in rockwool, there will invariably be some room reflections, and the strongest of these should be either absorbed or diverted before they reach your main listening position. In professional studios there are clever tricks that you can do with wall angles to divert reflections. However, most home studios use rectangular rooms, so that's what I'll concentrate on here.
StudioSOS RajDhamuDiag
Diagram: Tom Flint
Here you can see several of the mistakes commonly made in setting up monitors in the home studio. For a start, a number of factors are compromising the stereo imaging: the speakers being on their sides, their asymmetrical placement in the room, and the insufficient angling of the drivers towards the monitoring position. Also, the right-hand speaker is placed directly in a corner of the room, while the left-hand speaker doesn't appear to be mounted on any particularly solid — both of these factors would have an impact on the bass performance.
Reflections from the desk and other nearby equipment can be a big problem, so sorting out the location of the monitors themselves should be the first priority before fixing up any acoustic treatment. First of all, the monitors should usually be used the 'right way up', because lying them on their sides will compromise the stereo image significantly. Ideally, the speakers should also be on stands that put them at head height, and the drivers should be angled so as to point towards your head. Avoid putting the monitors too far into the room's corners, and observe the manufacturer's recommendations on how far from any walls they need to be. For the best stereo imagining, it's also best to place them symmetrically in the room, ideally firing down the long axis in smaller rooms, and set up such that the speakers form two corners of an equilateral triangle, the third corner falling at or just behind the listening position.
It is important that no hardware, such as computer screens or racks, comes between you and your monitors, and that the desk surface is significantly lower than the monitors, so as to avoid strong reflections bouncing off the desk and into your face. If in doubt, put a mirror flat on your desk between you and the speakers, and if you can see the speaker, particularly the tweeter, when you look in the mirror, you have a potential reflection problem which should be addressed by moving the speakers if possible. Where the speakers must stand on a desk or shelf, foam isolation pads help keep the sound clean, and some products also provide a means to angle the speakers up or down if necessary.
The other consideration is that it helps not to have the speakers set up midway along any of the room's dimensions — so neither speaker should be exactly halfway between the side walls, or halfway between the floor and ceiling, for example. If two or more of these dimensions are equal, you could end up with bumps and dips in the low-end response, even if the rest of the room is acoustically acceptable.

The Sources Of Unwanted Reflections
Mid-range and high frequencies reflect from hard surfaces such as plaster or plasterboard walls in a similar way that light reflects from a mirror. The effect is not quite as exact as with a mirror, as some of the sound energy is scattered, and a little is absorbed, but in simple terms you can think of hard walls as approximate acoustic mirrors. If you put a mirror alongside a light bulb, you see the light bulb itself and also its image in the mirror. Both act as real sources of light as far as you, the observer, are concerned.
The same thing happens if you stand a speaker close to a hard wall — a phantom sound source is created by the reflection, so now you hear sound from both the speaker and the wall. If you know which part of the wall is responsible for reflecting the phantom image to your mixing chair, then you can concentrate your acoustic treatment in that area. In fact, you can use a real mirror to find out where that spot is by getting a friend to hold the mirror up flat against the wall at different locations until you're able to see an image of your loudspeaker from the mixing position. It's for this reason that we often refer to these areas as the 'mirror points'.
StudioSOS Mirror Poin#A2661
This diagram shows how to apply basic acoustic treatment to a typical home-studio room. The absorber panels shown in purple are the most important, but adding in the orange absorbers would improve the situation further. Acoustic foam is a common choice of absorber in this application. If bass trapping is required, then it is usually most effective applied in the room corners (including those corners between any of the walls and the ceiling). Note also the angles and positions of the monitors with comparison to the listening position — arranging the three points in an equilateral triangle will help give a natural stereo image.
In a normal home studio setup (a rectangular room with a flat ceiling), there will be images on the side walls and ceiling between you and the speakers. Strictly speaking, there will also be one on the floor, but the chances are that this will be obscured by the desk holding your equipment. Clearly, we can also hear sounds from behind us, so the rear wall will also be a source of reflections, plus there will be reflections from the wall directly behind the speakers, and all these need to be considered when applying acoustic treatment.
Once you have identified the main reflection points, you can place treatment there to absorb the sound and kill the reflections. Bear in mind, though, that most people tend to move around a bit while recording and mixing, so the absorber panels need to be fairly large if they are to cover all possible reflection points as we move around.

Effective & Ineffective Absorbers
Now you've probably read about Technical Editor Hugh Robjohns and I sticking acoustic foam onto studio walls, but before you rush off and do this it is important to understand the limitations of such materials. While a thick black cloth placed over a mirror will absorb all the visible light of its reflection, a piece of acoustic foam will only be acoustically 'black' at high frequencies, becoming increasingly transparent at lower frequencies. In very general terms, a piece of four-inch-thick foam stuck directly onto the wall is only really effective for frequencies above about 200-300Hz, whereas a piece of two-inch foam is only effective above about 400-600Hz. In other words, if you halve the thickness of the foam, the frequency above which it is effective moves up by an octave.
Once you appreciate this, you can see immediately why attempts to deaden walls with carpet don't work too well — carpet is relatively thin and so only soaks up very high frequencies. This leaves the low and mid-range frequencies unaffected, giving a dull and boxy result. You can probably now also understand why acoustic foam would need to be several feet thick to be effective at bass frequencies, which is why foam is rarely the most practical solution for bass absorption.
Although foam is quite convenient, it's not the only option. You can also use one or more layers of high-density Rockwool insulation slab, as long as you cover it with fabric to keep those nasty irritating fibres out of the air. Rockwool is just as effective as foam, if not more so, but it does require more in the way of DIY skills.
One very useful tip is that spacing foam or Rockwool absorbers away from your wall by a few inches makes them more effective at low frequencies. For example, spacing four-inch-thick foam four inches from the wall is almost as effective as using double the thickness of foam in the first place! It can help in this instance to mount the foam or Rockwool onto a board with large holes or slots cut out of it to let the sound through — radiator fret panel is good for this, but not pegboard. This board can then be hung in the right place. Another quicker solution is to simply glue high-density foam cubes to the back of an acoustic-foam panel to act as spacers. I've found that spray carpet adhesive is as good as anything for fixing foam.
Another way to deal with high-frequency reflections is to break them up so that they become less disruptive. This is called 'diffusion', and requires a very uneven surface with protrusions and wells several inches in depth. Although commercial diffuser designs are available with precisely calculated profiles, putting shelves at the back of your room and part filling them with books, manuals, CDs and bits of unused gear also works quite effectively!
StudioSOS PaulAssemblesFoam
StudioSOS Brett at Desk
Normally acoustic foam panels will act primarily on mid-range and high-frequency reflections, but you can improve the low-frequency absorption effects by spacing the panels a few inches from the wall surface — the easiest way to do this is simply to stick small off-cuts of foam to the back of each panel as spacers (left). For best results, fix the panels across the room's corners (right).
In a normal home studio, 2 x 4-foot panels of foam are convenient to manage, and one panel would typically be fixed to each side wall at the mirror points, with a third at the ceiling mirror point if the ceiling were low enough to cause problems. The next step up from this would be to add further panels behind the monitors, as reflections from this area are potentially very confusing, given that they come from almost the same point in space as the speakers themselves. All these foam panels should be centred according to the engineer's head height when he or she is in the monitoring position. Finally, the rear wall needs to be addressed, which is often best done by combining areas of absorption (foam and sofas!) with areas of scattering.

Room Modes & Low End
In most project studios, dealing with reflections will already vastly improve the stereo imaging and focus of the sound, but some further bass treatment will probably be desirable to even out the bass response in the room, especially if you have monitors that work down to very low frequencies. Bass problems are associated with room modes, which are resonances relating to the room's dimensions — you get them at any frequency with a half-wavelength (or multiple of half-wavelengths) which matches any of the room dimensions. The smaller the room, the more widely spaced the modal frequencies are, so it becomes more likely that the bass response will be uneven.
Depending on the room dimensions, some bass frequencies will be cancelled due to reflections coming back off the wall out of phase with the source, whereas at other frequencies the reflections will be in phase, leading to a boost in level at that frequency. You can often hear these peaks and dips quite plainly from your listening position when you play a chromatic sequence of equal-level bass notes through your monitors. Hugh and I have found particular problems in small rooms that are approximately cuboid in shape, as these often exhibit a big 'hole' in the bass end in the dead centre of the room. What's worse, though, is that the engineer's chair very often ends up being positioned right on the dead spot in such small rooms!
Although low frequencies can be treated using porous absorbers such as foam or rockwool, the treatment needs to be quite thick and also carefully positioned. Where you have a deep ceiling void, you can utilise this as a bass trap by cutting large holes in the ceiling and then stuffing the void with Rockwool, after which the access holes can be covered with acoustically transparent fabric. The same goes for fireplaces, alcoves, or other unused spaces.
StudioSOS BassTrap01a#A265F
Because of the way bass energy propagates, traps in the corners of the room (both vertical and horizontal) are the most effective. You can't usually make these several feet deep, but you can at least make them several feet long by having them go from floor to ceiling, or all along the length of a wall/ceiling junction. Various companies make big foam wedges that can be glued into corners, but you need quite a lot of them to make a real difference. They are also quite expensive, though you can cheat a little by putting flat foam panels across the corners on wooden frames, then filling the inside of each structure with dense rockwool. Fortunately, there are other ways to absorb bass other than by thick porous absorbers.
The main reason that low-frequency energy bounces off solid walls is that the walls don't move significantly — they neither absorb much of the bass energy nor allow much to pass through. The outcome is that most of the low frequency energy ends up back in the room. Of course sound doesn't really 'pass through' any airtight panel, but sound does cause that panel to vibrate, those vibrations producing sound at the other side of the panel. This gives us another clue as how we might absorb bass energy.
One classic method is to fix a resonant panel over a box containing an acoustically absorbent material. The sound energy forces the panel to resonate and, in the process, some of the sound energy is dissipated by the panel and internal absorber. However, this type of trap works only on or around the resonant frequency of the panel, and it also returns some unwanted energy back into the room because the panel tends to continue resonating for a short time after the incident sound energy has stopped.
Another way to prevent low-frequency sound bouncing is to interrupt it with a heavy but non-rigid surface. Here the principle is the same as when bouncing a ball off concrete and then trying to bounce it off dry sand. Clearly the ball will bounce higher from the concrete than from the sand. (In fact, sand can be quite a useful acoustic material, but its weight makes it impractical in most home studio applications other than for filling hollow speaker stands.) A far better option is to use a material called 'barrier mat' or 'dead sheet', which is essentially a floppy vinyl sheet (not unlike heavy flooring vinyl) loaded with lead or mineral particles to make it heavy. This weighs about 10-20kg per square metre and allows very simple and effective traps to be constructed with minimal depth.
StudioSOS BassTrap02a#A2660
There are many variations on the 'barrier-mat trap' theme, but the general idea is that you hang the material a few inches from a wall and then hang or fix a porous absorber in front of it to absorb the high frequency energy that the surface of the sheet would otherwise reflect back into the room. Using this technique, an effective full-range trap can be created in a box-shaped space less then 12 inches deep. The greater the surface area, the more energy the trap will absorb. Where the back wall of the studio is less than around 10 feet from the monitoring position, this can be a useful way to treat the entire back wall.
A halfway house between the absorber and non-rigid-sheet approaches is used in some of the Real Traps products, where a thick slab of absorber has a thin, non-porous sheet fixed to one face. Simply put, the sound energy tries to make the sheet move, but the damping material to which it is fixed dissipates the energy. These traps work best when spaced away from the wall or, better still, when fixed across corners.
While you need to be careful not to apply too much high-frequency trapping in a room, it is very difficult to go too far with bass trapping, and as a rule the more you can accommodate, the more even your bass response will be. Some people worry that bass trapping will mean less bass in the room, but this is not the case at all. The trapping removes the reflected bass, and reflected bass often cancels out the wanted bass from the speakers. The result is actually a clearer, tighter, and more uniform bass response, free from booms and weak or missing notes. However, in a lot of cases a complete solution is not practical, so in smaller home studios as much bass trapping as possible should be combined with the simple expedient of making sure that the mixing chair is out of the way of any sonic 'Bermuda Triangles'.